Showing posts with label egyptology. Show all posts
Showing posts with label egyptology. Show all posts

Akhenaten: The Heretic King Review

Akhenaten: The Heretic King
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
The author portrays Akhenaten more as an atheist than a monotheist. A striking portrait is an outline of this fascinating 'worshiper of the sun', who is also one of the best known pharaohs. A good overview is provided of the Akhenaten Temple Project. Some of the author's comments are amusing which makes the book more enjoyable especially through the 'dry' moments. The book contains a short glossary, suggested readings, and many black and white illustrations and drawings. It is recommended for the open-minded lay person.

Click Here to see more reviews about: Akhenaten: The Heretic King

Describes the world of Akhenaten, a ruler of ancient Egypt who attempted to introduce monotheism through worship of thesun.

Buy Now

Click here for more information about Akhenaten: The Heretic King

Read More...

Life in Ancient Egypt Review

Life in Ancient Egypt
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
Adolf Erman did a very fine job on writing this book. It basically covers what it was like to live along the Nile in Ancient times. His writing is very easy to understand and I recommend it to teachers to read to their classes. Unlike some other books, this one does not just talk about the well known pharaohs but some that I have never even heard of. He also includes many special events. This book was the best I have ever read about Egyptology and covers everything anyone would need to know.

Click Here to see more reviews about: Life in Ancient Egypt

The fullest, most thoroughly detailed account - including much material not found in more recent books - of domestic life, religion, magic, medicine, commerce, and much more in ancient Egypt. Many illustrations reproduce tomb paintings, carvings, and hieroglyphs.

Buy NowGet 22% OFF

Click here for more information about Life in Ancient Egypt

Read More...

Out of Egypt: The Roots of Christianity Revealed Review

Out of Egypt: The Roots of Christianity Revealed
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
I was intrigued by the thesis of this book; that the roots of both Judaism and Christianity were to be found in ancient Egypt. Amongst other ideas, the author suggests that the Pharaohs Thutmosis III, Akhenaten, and Tutankamun were the persons that the Bible calls David, Moses, and Jesus, respectively. He argues that the accounts in the scriptures held sacred by the Jews and by Christians, known as the Old Testament, and which were written down only after many centuries of oral tradition, are seriously flawed and ahistorical. Osman further suggests that there is no proof whatsoever, aside from the biblical account, that there ever was an important Jewish kingdom in Palestine ruled by David or Solomon. Essentially, he contends that Jesus did not live a mortal life in the first century AD, but rather that embellished accounts of a life from more than 1000 years earlier were used as a model in what amounted to a great deception. His book is a serious problem for either a believing Christian or a believing Jew, undercutting as it does the veracity of the scriptures, and basic tenets of both faiths. Nonetheless, the book might be a serious challenge to conventional scholarship, were it not flawed itself. Osman has an annoying and ultimately self-undermining habit of making a great many unsupported suppositions. He makes a claim, which he promises to prove "later", and then later he continues his argument with "As we have seen..." as though he has offered solid proof, when in fact he has offered nothing of the sort. There is far too much here that lacks substantiation, and the author relies far too heavily on the Bible itself (which he himself claims is completely unreliable) and his personal interpretation thereof, to measure up to even a weak academic standard. It IS an entertaining read; but far too many speculations are held together with very little solid evidence for Osman's argument to be taken completely seriously. Even his research was less than thorough. His bibliography, for example, does not include Immanuel Velikovsky, who wrote of a similar theory regarding the Pharaoh Akhenaten decades ago. To conclude, the book promised much, but failed to deliver. Ultimately, I was disappointed.

Click Here to see more reviews about: Out of Egypt: The Roots of Christianity Revealed



Buy Now

Click here for more information about Out of Egypt: The Roots of Christianity Revealed

Read More...

Ancient Egypt and Black Africa Review

Ancient Egypt and Black Africa
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
Dr. Theophile Obenga has written a great book showing the African background to Greek philosophy. The book traces the Greek student's routes when travelling to Egypt in addition to providing the words of the students themselves and their references to learning in Egypt. Dr. Obenga's mastery of ancient Greek and Medu Netcher (hieroglyphics) provides the reader with the words of the ancients themselves. This book should be required reading for all college students. Dr. Obenga's arguments make the book, Not Out of Africa, by Mary Lefkowitz seem almost juvenile.

Click Here to see more reviews about: Ancient Egypt and Black Africa



Buy Now

Click here for more information about Ancient Egypt and Black Africa

Read More...

Theodosia and the Serpents of Chaos Review

Theodosia and the Serpents of Chaos
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
Should I be embarrassed that I am a 50-ish woman who took one little skim of this book and got all the way hooked, snuck it from my son, and read it cover to cover? WOW! I am the kind of person who has 5 or 6 books started all over the house; who reads snippets wherever I sit down. Theodosia and the Serpents of Chaos grabbed my imagination and took me on a mystical and suspenseful adventure, full of Ancient Egyptian artifacts, swirling curses and lively heiroglyphs. I met Theodosia's cute but pesky little brother Henry, and a heroic pickpocketing street urchin, Sticky Will, among many others. One of my favorites was Isis, the hapless kitty that became the recepticle for some dark curses Theodosia tried to remove from one of the ancient vases. I could go on and on about how much fun this story was to read, but I'd better not give any more away. I won't tell you that it was on Theodosia's shoulders to save the whole country of England, or that she had to find a way to go to Egypt and visit some tombs for herself. A real feat for an 11 year old girl. I just CAN'T tell you how she managed to get there, or how scary the dark tunnels to the tombs were. You just need to read it for yourself! If there was anything I would change about this book, it would only be to make the story longer. I hope R.L.LaFevers decides to make this only the first of Theodosia's many adventures.

Click Here to see more reviews about: Theodosia and the Serpents of Chaos



Buy Now

Click here for more information about Theodosia and the Serpents of Chaos

Read More...

The Roots of Our Faith: Ancient Egypt And The Bible Review

The Roots of Our Faith: Ancient Egypt And The Bible
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
I've got to be more careful about self-published works - usually there's a reason no reputable publishing house will take them. I purchased this book because it looked interesting. I've gotten interested in both ancient Egypt and the early roots of Christianity. I've long sensed that there is some overlap - after all, according to the Bible, Joseph and Mary fled with Jesus into Egypt to escape Herod's persecutions, so it wouldn't be surprising that Jesus might have picked up some Egyptian religion and mixed it with the Judaism He was raised with. I thought perhaps this book would explore such connections. But instead it is a rambling, disjointed, free-floating diatribe about all the ills of society being traceable to the exclusion of the Bible from public education and Christians' racist refusal to see the roots of Christianity in ancient African-Egyptian civilization.
For a shorter review, I should focus on what the book got right - I could stop here. I'm not even sure where to begin to address the flaws of this book. Ocansey's "logic" seems to be roughly: Egypt was the earliest civilization; early Egyptians mapped the "heavens" in the Zodiac, which is God's blueprint of His plan for the world, including Jesus Christ; the Egyptians were monotheistic and worshipped the same "God Almighty" as in the Bible; Egypt is in Africa; denying the Egyptian roots of Christianity is racist way of excluding the real African roots of Christianity, based on the racist theory of evolution; the theory of evolution is but one manifest aspect of the evil influence of Satan in the world, which is responsible for all the world's ills; and finally, if public school children are denied learning about Christianity and its true roots in ancient Egypt, they will of necessity be left in utter darkness and society will stumble toward it's ultimate destruction.
So much of this book was so patently and obviously wrong that I feel rather foolish refuting it. But, nonetheless, here goes. First, Egypt was not the only ancient civilization. If you search "cradle of civilization", you'll get more hits for ancient Mesopotamia than you will for Egypt. Also, there is growing evidence that the Norte Chico people in ancient Peru had vast and complex civilizations - complete with pyramids - that pre-date Egyptian civilization.
Second, Ocansey's claims about the Zodiac are just baffling, such as his claim that the Zodiac belongs under the rubric of astronomy, not astrology. Nevermind the fact that the constellations reference nothing other than the random distribution of stars and other "heavenly bodies" throughout the universe. But even to whatever extent the Zodiac is a valid "chart" of the "heavens", Ocansey's interpretation thereof was, to say the least, stretching it. If you read that section, I'd suggest smoking something stronger than tobacco - it might make more sense then. Being as most Christian denominations view the Zodiac as part of the occult, I don't think Ocansey is going to find wide-spread acceptance of his views on the subject.
Third, the idea that ancient Egyptians were monotheistic is just laughable. They had a pantheon of gods to rival the Greeks, Romans, Norse and even the Hindus. Ocansey, however, argues that they had a sort of underlying monotheism because they recognized that there was one "God Almighty" (Ra) who created everything; the other gods are just aspects of the One God, sort of like Jesus and the Holy Spirit are aspects of God. But by that view, Hinduism is also monotheistic. Again, I don't see widespread acceptance by Christians adopting Ocansey's view that Egyptian religion is the same as Christianity. After all, the Egyptians worshipped their Pharaohs as gods, and only Pharaohs (and those they needed to serve them in the afterlife) were eligible for life after death. Admittedly, Ocansey refers to one Pharaoh in particular - Akhenaton - who introduced monotheism (or a form thereof), but Akhenaton's religion died out with his death, and even he essentially worshipped the Sun.
Fourth, ancient Egypt was not "black" in any way that can be directly connected to modern "black culture". While there is still vast disagreement about what race the ancient Egyptians were, there is more of a consensus that the concept isn't even relevant. The ancient Egyptians portrayed themselves in statutes and wall paintings in a variety of hues from white to pink to brown to black and with a variety of features from stereotypical African features to stereotypical European, Semitic and Asian features. But in any case, their culture flourished three to five thousand years ago and was at the crossroads of many different cultures and civilizations. To say that ancient Egyptians were "black" is not only possibly inaccurate, it's rather meaningless as culture and civilization have changed (evolved!) drastically since then.
Finally, Ocansey is stuck in the old canard that only the Bible represents "Truth". Science is meaningless because it only focuses on what can be experienced and studied, while "God's truth" transcends sensory and rational knowledge to achieve a level of "revelation" knowledge. That may or may not be, but how is it, then that no two believers agree on precisely what "God's truth" is? Even if we were to grant Ocansey's wish to teach the "truth" about God and Jesus Christ, whose truth would we teach? Catholic? Mainline Protestant? Evangelical?
Ocansey really vents his spleen on "evolutionary theory" throughout the book. It is the work of Satan responsible for all the evil in the world including, interestingly, Europeans' attitudes towards blacks and Native Americans which allowed for slavery and other oppression. Nevermind that Darwin didn't even develop the theory of evolution until hundreds of years after the slave trade had begun. And nevermind that there are just as many (if not more) religious justifications for slavery and racism as there are secular ones. The South has never exactly been known as a hotbed of Enlightenment science. It is, however, part of the Bible Belt. Nothing will convince people like Ocansey that the "theory" of evolution is every bit as much proven science as the "theory" of gravity, but that shouldn't mean that he gets to impose his "beliefs" about "science" on public school kids.
Ocansey also argues that there are no values, morals or self-discipline without God. There are only two choices: God or Satan; good or evil. If you don't teach kids about God, they will have no way to learn about good, no reason to discipline themselves or behave better than animals. I'd say Buddhist monks who fast and meditate for days or weeks at a time would be surprised to learn that they have no self-discipline. If only the world were as black and white as Ocansey paints - how easy it would all be.
Perhaps the most unsettling things about this book are that Ocansey received two masters and a Ph.D. from Columbia (I'm guessing they don't look at those as their finest moments) and that he has been involved in public education in New York City for over thirty years. I do hope his work has been administrative. I hope that no public school children have actually been exposed to either his bizarre theology or his bad science.


Click Here to see more reviews about: The Roots of Our Faith: Ancient Egypt And The Bible

This book seeks to set Christianity "right-side up on its feet" by acknowledging its ancient Egyptian roots.Concepts, ideas and beliefs mapped out in the Zodiac or recorded in the Egyptian Book of the Dead became the source of much that we find in the Bible. It documents that creation doctrine taught by ancient Egyptians, and recorded in the Bible, was superseded by Evolutionary theory which distorted many of those ideas. Man, believed to be God's creation as spirit, soul and body became a "higher animal" according to evolutionary theory. Hierarchies of man emerged with the "higher" not assigned to ancient Egyptian Blacks but to Whites, while Blacks were even considered subhuman. The foundation was laid for racism and man's inhumanity to man as evidenced by slavery and the holocaust.Today color discrimination and segregation still exist, thanks to evolutionary theory. Since this philosophy still controls American Public school education, children are denied the knowledge of God with such truths, ideas and concepts that had their foundation in ancient Egypt. Consequently, students are exposed to the deception of Satan without the countervailing Power of God through the Holy Spirit, Who alone transforms individuals from the ordinary to the extraordinary.

Buy Now

Click here for more information about The Roots of Our Faith: Ancient Egypt And The Bible

Read More...

The Oxford Encyclopedia of Ancient Egypt: 3 Volume Set Review

The Oxford Encyclopedia of Ancient Egypt: 3 Volume Set
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
The most complete source that can be found on the subject of ancient Egypt. It contains everything one would want to know about the civilization in an easy to use fashion. Written by the who's who of egyptology and covering its entire history.
There are a couple problems with the encyclopedia. The first is that most of the pictures are in black and white and of a lower quality. The most frustrating problem is that different aritcles sometimes use different spellings for the same god or person for example, the goddess of Lower Egypt can be found spelled Wadjet, Wadjyt, and in one article she is reffered to as Uto and in the caption to the picture on the same page she is reffered to using Edjo. Each spelling has to be refferenced in the glossary seperately, only showing the the page indicating to that particular spelling and not the rest. This makes it somewhat more difficult to find certain information (familiarize yourself with as many spellings as possible).
These shortcomings are small and aren't enough to lower its score. What remains most improtant is that it is still the best, most up-to-date, and accessible reference work out there (a five all the way).

Click Here to see more reviews about: The Oxford Encyclopedia of Ancient Egypt: 3 Volume Set



Buy NowGet 15% OFF

Click here for more information about The Oxford Encyclopedia of Ancient Egypt: 3 Volume Set

Read More...

House of Eternity: The Tomb of Nefertari (Conservation and Cultural Heritage Series) Review

House of Eternity: The Tomb of Nefertari (Conservation and Cultural Heritage Series)
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
Books about Ancient Egypt usually deal with her Pharaoh's, the State Religion, Ancient Monuments or art treasures . Little is known about most of the Queens of Ancient Egypt. The better known queens, Hatchepsut and Cleopatra ruled in their own right. Nefertari was the principle wife of one of Ancient Egypt's greatest Pharaoh's, Ramesses the Great. Ramesses built many temples and monuments during his long reign, some of which are still standing today including the Ramesseum, and the two Temple's at Abu Simbel. The smaller temple was dedicated to Nefertari. Very few temples or monuments were dedicated to anyone but the Pharaoh or one of the many Gods. The book " House of Eternity, The Tomb of Nefertari" tells as much of the story of Queen Nefertari as is known today. The Tomb of Nefertari is one of the most beautiful surviving monuments of Pharaonic Egypt. Since the Tomb was discovered in 1904, much damage has been caused by tourists. The tomb was closed to the public and preservation of the artwork undertaken by the Getty Institute. The tomb was re-opened to the public in 1995.. This book gives the reader a guided tour of the Tomb. The pictures in the book are spectacular.The author John McDonald takes the reader through the construction and decoration of the tomb, and then guides the reader through the journey into the Egyptian afterlife undertaken by Nefertari. The pictures on the tomb walls are from the Book of the Dead and the meaning of each is explained as Nefertari travels from the doorway of her tomb to her final resting place. I would rate this book as an essential addition to the library of anyone seriously interested in the history of Ancient Egypt and would advise anyone planning to visit the Tomb to read the book before hand.

Click Here to see more reviews about: House of Eternity: The Tomb of Nefertari (Conservation and Cultural Heritage Series)



Buy Now

Click here for more information about House of Eternity: The Tomb of Nefertari (Conservation and Cultural Heritage Series)

Read More...

Tutankhamun's Tomb: The Thrill of Discovery: Photographs by Harry Burton (Metropolitan Museum of Art) Review

Tutankhamun's Tomb: The Thrill of Discovery: Photographs by Harry Burton (Metropolitan Museum of Art)
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
If you thought you'd seen everything there was to see about the discovery of the tomb of Tutankhamun, you were wrong! This amazing book is an invaluable addition to the Tut library. I picked up a copy of the book while visiting the Metropolitan Museum, and I can't recommend this book highly enough. The original excavation photos are beautiful and truly give you a sense of what it must have been like to witness the discovery of the tomb. From photos of the landscape in the Valley of the Kings (setting the geographic scene), to photos of the excavators working on the tomb through to object photos, the entire story of the discovery of the tomb is illustrated. Despite their age, the photos are vivid and gorgeous and bring the discovery to life. The accompanying text is kept to a minimum -- narrating the story nicely, but allowing the photos and objects to speak for themselves. (Longer photo captions at the end of the book accompany thumbnail photos, giving more detailed information about each photography.) This book will make a welcome addition to the library of anyone who loves ancient Egypt, a beautiful coffee table book, a nice backdrop or preparation for the King Tut show that's touring, or a lovely gift for anyone interested in Egypt or archaeology.

Click Here to see more reviews about: Tutankhamun's Tomb: The Thrill of Discovery: Photographs by Harry Burton (Metropolitan Museum of Art)

This richly illustrated book of vintage photographs commemorates one of the most memorable episodes in the history of archaeology: the discovery and exploration in 1922 of the tomb of the ancient Egyptian pharaoh Tutankhamun (Dynasty 18, ruled ca. 1336–1327 B.C.). These photographs, documenting every stage in the process of discovery, were taken by the renowned archaeological photographer Harry Burton. Burton was a staff member of the Metropolitan Museum Egyptian Expedition when he was "lent" to Howard Carter, the famed excavator of Tutankhamun's tomb.From the rock-cut steps leading down to the entrance passage, to the opening of the sealed chambers inside, to the first view of the contents of the tomb and the removal of the objects, Burton's beautiful black-and-white photographs show thousands of the richly made and decorated objects found in the tomb. Carefully reproduced from Burton's original prints, the photographs are accompanied by new descriptive text written by two prominent Egyptologists with extensive knowledge of the history of Tutankhamun and the contents of his tomb.

Buy NowGet 27% OFF

Click here for more information about Tutankhamun's Tomb: The Thrill of Discovery: Photographs by Harry Burton (Metropolitan Museum of Art)

Read More...

Egyptology Code-Writing Kit (Ologies) Review

Egyptology Code-Writing Kit (Ologies)
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
my daughter has gone egyptain..lol she loves this kit...it came with card and stickers and she learned how to read hyrogliphics....this is a great product for the bigginner and it has lead to many egptian movies and books....

Click Here to see more reviews about: Egyptology Code-Writing Kit (Ologies)



Buy Now

Click here for more information about Egyptology Code-Writing Kit (Ologies)

Read More...

Amelia Peabody's Egypt: A Compendium Review

Amelia Peabody's Egypt: A Compendium
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
AMELIA PEABODY'S EGYPT: A COMPENDIUM is a collection of articles about Egypt and Victorian culture, 19th century Egyptian history, early archeology, and a comprehensive listing of places and people (both fictional and historical) that are listed in the growing collection of Amelia Peabody historical mysteries. The compendium also includes a huge number of period photographs and etchings that depict Egypt and archeological digs as they existed in the time when Emerson and Amelia were digging, solving mysteries, and confounding the German/Turkish invaders.
Readers looking for a detailed history of Victorian Egypt should probably look elsewhere for their primary material but will want to consider adding the compendium as a secondary source. But fans of the Elizabeth Peters mystery series can hardly go wrong with this fascinating look at the culture and history of Egyptology.
Recommendation--if you're a Peters fan, print out this review and leave it where present-giving significant others will find it. Underline the words 'MUST HAVE.' Alternately, buy it for yourself. The pictures alone are worth the price and then some. It's a treasure.

Click Here to see more reviews about: Amelia Peabody's Egypt: A Compendium



Buy NowGet 34% OFF

Click here for more information about Amelia Peabody's Egypt: A Compendium

Read More...

Hatshepsut, His Majesty, Herself Review

Hatshepsut, His Majesty, Herself
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
"Hatshepsut, His Majesty, Herself" is a very good book for children or people who just want a straight forward history of the first succesful female pharoah in ancient Egypt. This was the first book I read of Hatshepsut and I enjoyed it alot. It encouraged me to begin to learn more about her. She was truly a great ruler and worth investigating further. The book consists of a basic history of Hatshepsut and her accomplishments. If you liked this book check out a longer young adult novel "His Majesty, Queen Hatshepsut" by 'Dorothy Sharp Carter'.

Click Here to see more reviews about: Hatshepsut, His Majesty, Herself



Buy Now

Click here for more information about Hatshepsut, His Majesty, Herself

Read More...

The Tomb-Builders of the Pharaohs Review

The Tomb-Builders of the Pharaohs
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
The valley of the Kings in Egypt has enticed numerous archeologists in search of the burial sites of the Pharoahs. These remarkable tombs were built by skilled workers who had a special city built for them and their families. Mr. Bierbrier has researched and done a scholarly work about these workers and their day to day lives. We learn that the more things change, the more they stay the same, as the same day to day and family problems that we have today are very much the same as those who lived 3,000 years ago. It is certainly a distant mirror and one that students of Egypt will enjoy. It is well written and I am particularly proud of this book as Mr. Bierbrier is a cousin of mine. This however did not affect my opinion of this fine work.

Click Here to see more reviews about: The Tomb-Builders of the Pharaohs

This fascinating study brings to life the people who lived and died at Deir el-Medina over three thousand years ago--the workers who built the tombs of the pharaohs in the nearby Valley of the Kings. Dr. Bierbrier draws on the thousands of documents, letters, literary texts, and drawings found at the site to give an intimate glimpse of life in the village.

Buy Now

Click here for more information about The Tomb-Builders of the Pharaohs

Read More...

Jewels of the Pharaohs: Egyptian Jewelry of the Dynastic Period Review

Jewels of the Pharaohs: Egyptian Jewelry of the Dynastic Period
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
I have always been interested in ancient Egypt but this book focused on the jewelry, which I had only read about in general terms.
In the section about the recovery of ancient Egyptian jewelry, the author talked about how discoveries are more often made by accident than by a deliberate, planned search. Many treasures have been dispersed all over the world because of being found by private persons.
Materials were selected for their color rather than for their "refractive powers, brilliance, or rarity."
Next the author discussed the uses of jewelry in ancient Egypt. Jewelry was used for personal adornment of men as much as for women, and used in burials, for the shrines of the gods, and as temple furnishings. The most common use of jewelry was as amulets - to protect the wearers from harm.
The materials used by craftsmen to make jewelry in ancient Egypt were shells, horns, tusks, claws, stones, and gold. Some of the most popular stones were carnellian, lapis lazuli, and turquoise (very different from the veiny turquoise we see here in the U.S).
A very informative book.

Click Here to see more reviews about: Jewels of the Pharaohs: Egyptian Jewelry of the Dynastic Period



Buy Now

Click here for more information about Jewels of the Pharaohs: Egyptian Jewelry of the Dynastic Period

Read More...

Monarchs of the Nile Review

Monarchs of the Nile
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
This book provides a compact chronicle of the most significant Egyptian monarchs from the earliest times to the end of Nektanebo II's reign. The lives and achievements of these rulers (famous or lesser-known kings and queens) are clearly summarized and accurately detailed. Well illustrated in black and white, this book is mostly recommended for students.

Click Here to see more reviews about: Monarchs of the Nile

This book presents a concise account of the lives and times of some of the more significant occupants of the Egyptian throne, from the unification of the country around 3000 BC down to the extinction of native rule just under three millennia later. Some, such as Tuthmosis III, had a major impact on their time, and were remembered by their own people until the very civilization collapsed. Others, such as Tutankhamun, were soon forgotten by the Egyptians themselves, only to burst into popular culture thousands of years after their deaths, as a result of the labors of modern archeologists. Still more remain unknown outside the small circle of professional archeologists, but led lives that call out for wider dissemination. This book sets out to provide a mix of all three categories, in an attempt to present a balanced view of Egyptian kings and their range of achievements.

Buy Now

Click here for more information about Monarchs of the Nile

Read More...

Abydos: Egypt's First Pharaohs and the Cult of Osiris (New Aspects of Antiquity) Review

Abydos: Egypt's First Pharaohs and the Cult of Osiris (New Aspects of Antiquity)
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
David O'Connor has been excavating at Abydos since 1967 -- probably his most famous find is the series of boats near the enclosures of Khasekhemwy (Shunet el Zebib) and the Western Mastaba -- and so is well-qualified to author this valuable and comprehensive work on the site. O'Connor pulls together the history of the development of the site and its excavation, as well as discussing the significance of various discoveries. It is an excellent, and well thought out compendium. The book is easy to read and well written, but intended for those with at least some knowledge of the subject matter, not absolute beginners.
Especially valuable, and sometimes difficult to find elsewhere, is the information on more recent discoveries and theories. To provide a few examples: he discusses the excavations by Stephen Harvey at the Ahmose complex, Janet Richards at the North and Middle Cemeteries, Josef Wegner at the Senwosret III complex, Mary-Ann Pouls Wegner's survey of the cultic landscape, the Akhenaten talatat found at the Ramesses II temple, and the theories of Gunter Dreyer regarding the early hieroglyphic signs from Tomb U-j. This is almost priceless information - much of it is only available in more expensive, subscription or foreign language publications. The discussions here are, of course, often much briefer than are available elsewhere, and O'Connor does supply a bibliography for further reading (and I've added a few links at the end of this review).
O'Connor deals with many theories (tomb development, the meaning of various symbolic elements such as mounds and pyramids, etc.), and he is one of the few Egyptologists who seems willing to say that in many cases the limited data available is sometimes open to more than one interpretation. He fairly treats competing theories, but this is also quite a personal work by him, and he is not hesitant to offer his opinion. He also points out that excavations are ongoing and there is still much work to do, and so it is only proper to expect new information to change many ideas.
The subtitle of the book refers to "Egypt's First Pharaohs and the Cult of Osiris." O'Connor deals extensively with those topics, but makes it clear to the reader how the later history of the site adds to our understanding of the earlier history. In fact, much of the information on the first kings comes later in the book, after the groundwork is laid. That may sound confusing, but it makes perfect sense in the context of the book.
Below is a list of the chapters and, in parentheses, my notes on some topics discussed in each.
1.The Discovery of Abydos (early excavations).
2.Osiris - Eternal Lord Who Presides in Abydos (the Osiris mythology).
3.The Temple of Seti I (the history of the beautiful temple and the Osireion).
4.The Rediscovery of Abydos (the second wave of excavations, including those of O'Connor himself).
5.The Evolution of a Sacred Landscape (the Old Kingdom and the First Intermediate Period).
6.The Expanding Landscape of the Middle Kingdom (Abydos in the Middle Kingdom, including the Senwosret III complex and the memorial chapels).
7.The Landscape Completed: Abydos in the New Kingdom (the Ahmose complex, Thutmose III, Akhenaten (who may have had a structure at Abydos), the "Portal" Temple of Ramesses II).
8.The Climax of the Osiris Cult (the Late Period).
9.The Royal Tombs of Abydos (The Dynasty 0 and Early Dynastic tombs at Umm el Qa'ab).
10.The Mysterious Enclosures of Abydos (a fascinating chapter on the Shunet el Zebib and other enclosures - with some equally fascinating theories).
11.Boat Graves and Pyramid Origins (how the finds at Abydos relate).
12.Abydos: Summing-Up.
O'Connor ends with useful and current information on visiting Abydos.
Let me finish by thanking the publisher, Thames & Hudson, for another excellent work at a reasonable price. I have an extensive Egyptology library (over 700 books) and I am shocked at how many recent Egyptology books cost $100-$500, and so many are out of my price range. Of course, I understand that more people will buy a book like this than a specialized report, but still, the price tags on many other new books, and some reprints, are beyond explanation.
By the way, some other current publications referenced, available at Amazon, include Janet Richards' Society and Death in Ancient Egypt: Mortuary Landscapes of the Middle Kingdom and Josef Wegner's The Mortuary Temple of Senwosret III at Abydos (Publications of the Pennsylvania-Yale Expedition to Egypt). Also invaluable is The Archaeology and Art of Ancient Egypt: Essays in Honor of David B. O'Connor (Cahier).

Click Here to see more reviews about: Abydos: Egypt's First Pharaohs and the Cult of Osiris (New Aspects of Antiquity)



Buy NowGet 34% OFF

Click here for more information about Abydos: Egypt's First Pharaohs and the Cult of Osiris (New Aspects of Antiquity)

Read More...

The Murder of Tutankhamen Review

The Murder of Tutankhamen
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
Granted the evidence presented by this book is by no means conclusive, I've got to say that if more history books were written with this much verve, fewer kids would graduate school convinced that "history is boring." Brier loves what he does, and he's very well-read in it, and it shows. You get a real feel for the political intrigue of the time right after the heresies of Amarna, and he presents the information in such a way that you never forget that there are actually human personalities associated with these events. The book does a great job getting across the flavor of life in that time, and certainly it does convince me at least that something fishy was going on at the end of Tut's reign.
However, that said, I didn't find any of the medical/forensic evidence presented even slightly convincing (and the opening chapter with its dramatic film noir reenactment of the "murder" was a bit much). Tutankhamen's death itself at a young age isn't even suspicious given that there is a good chance he inherited Marfan Syndrome from his father, a disability which has an excellent track record of killing young. And given that the skull and body were grossly damaged by the funerary practices of the time, I don't feel that any solid conclusions can be drawn from the state of either. The political evidence that something fishy was happening is a lot more compelling than the physical evidence -- and Brier knows his Egyptian politics.
Brier clearly knows Egypt well, and loves it, and that intellect and enthusiasm shines through every word, making this book a more than worthwhile read as long as you have your critical filters in place. I look forward to more work from Brier. Even if you don't agree with his conclusions, you've got to admit -- if more historians were this engaging and presented history with this much texture and life, history'd be a whole lot more fun in school, wouldn't it?

Click Here to see more reviews about: The Murder of Tutankhamen



Buy Now

Click here for more information about The Murder of Tutankhamen

Read More...